Making Currency and Trade Imbalances Top Issues with China

From a Reuters interview with President Obama earlier in the week in anticipation of his trip to Asia, “Obama: strains unless US, China balance growth“:

[He] warned that the economic relationship between the two countries had become “deeply imbalanced” in recent decades, with a yawning trade gap and huge Chinese holdings of U.S. government debt.

Obama said he would be raising with Chinese leaders the sensitive issue of their yuan currency — which is seen by U.S. industry as significantly undervalued — as one factor contributing to the imbalances.

“As we emerge from an emergency situation, a crisis situation, I believe China will be increasingly interested in finding a model that is sustainable over the long term,” he said. “They have a huge amount of U.S. dollars that they are holding, so our success is important to them.”

“The flipside of that is that if we don’t solve some of these problems, then I think both economically and politically it will put enormous strains on the relationship.”

The Hill had a follow-up story, “Obama to China: Currency and trade imbalances a focal point,” with the NAM’s positive reaction.

I think it is significant he brought this up in an interview and it’s more than a passing comment,” said Pat Mears, who works on China issues for the National Association of Manufacturers. She said U.S. manufacturers don’t expect things to change overnight, but offered hope that China will again allow its currency to appreciate against the dollar, as it did for more than a year before the financial crisis hit in 2008.

And new stories on the cusp of his departure today.

China, Debt and Economic Policy

Politico, “Barack Obama’s China plan looks like George W. Bush’s.” The story delivers what the headline promises.

Frank Vargo, the NAM’s vice president for international economic affairs, commented on the context of Treasury Secretary Geithner’s trip given the current state of play:

Now more than ever, the two economies need each other,” said one observer from the business community. “The administration recognizes they need to maintain the right posture.”

And with markets already skittish, signs of significant tension between the two countries would have dire consequences for the global economy, said Frank Vargo, vice president for international economic affairs at the National Association of Manufacturers.

“Everybody’s looking at United States and China as really being the two principal players on the global economic scene. So if they start shouting at each other, this is bad for financial markets right now,” he said. “You’ve just got to be careful. It doesn’t mean you change your objectives.”

And from an earlier AP story, “Geithner wields little leverage in China talks“:

Click to continue reading “China, Debt and Economic Policy”

Pressing the Chinese on Currency Valuation, Effectively

It was important for Treasury Secretary-designate to flatly state that China is manipulating its currency. Everyone knows China’s currency is being held at an artificially low level, and it is necessary for the United States Government to acknowledge this in order to be able to approach the problem realistically. (See New York Times and WSJ stories.)

The next step is more difficult - how to get China’s currency appreciating again. The currency appreciated 21 percent against the dollar through July 2008 and then went flat as Chinese authorities decided they were concerned about China’s slipping export performance in the slowing world economy. The fact of the matter is that China’s continued currency manipulation is hurting their own economy and making their transition away from export-led growth more difficult. Yuan appreciation can be win-win.

The Treasury Secretary-Designate is properly concerned with China’s currency and as the next step needs to work within established international means to find a solution. During the campaign, then-candidate Obama saw the importance of a change in China’s currency practices and said he would use all the diplomatic avenues available to seek such a change. Certainly the International Monetary Fund can play a stronger role than it has in the past.

Geithner’s statements showed he wants to get China’s currency moving, but without precipitating a new global financial crisis. Global financial stability and further appreciation of China’s currency can and should go hand in hand, but all this needs to be done carefully and in a way calculated to achieve both objectives and contribute to a lessening of global imbalances.

The yuan per dollar graph below shows how China’s currency was moving until July 2008, and then was held flat.

 

 

 

Manipulating Currency, China

The New York Times reports that Tim Geithner, the nominee to be U.S. Secretary of Treasury, said in written responses to Senate Finance Committee inquiries that he believed China manipulates its currency. From the story, “Geithner Hints at Harder Line on China Trade“:

“President Obama — backed by the conclusions of a broad range of economists — believes that China is manipulating its currency,” Mr. Geithner wrote. He stopped short of charging that China is manipulating its currency intentionally to gain an unfair trade advantage, as the 1988 law requires for an official citation of currency “manipulation.”

The Times considers this page one news, seeing it as indication of a harder policy line against China’s economic policy. The NAM’s Frank Vargo, vice president for international economic policy, comments:

The National Association of Manufacturers, whose members have pushed previous administrations to get tougher with China, was pleased, but also cautious given the potential for a confrontation that could exacerbate global woes.

“You know the world has changed a lot with the financial crisis and China has a lot in U.S. Treasuries,” said Frank Vargo, vice president for international economic affairs at the manufacturers’ association. “This needs to be done in a cooperative, not a confrontational, way.”

 You would certainly hate to see President Obama repeat the mistakes of President Hoover and sign legislation that sparks a destructive round of protectionism worldwide.

UPDATE (9:45 a.m.): Wall Street Journal also reports, “U.S. Stance on the Yuan Gets Tougher“:

“You don’t want to be the bull in the China shop when it comes to currencies right now,” said Frank Vargo, a vice president of the National Association of Manufacturers, which has long lobbied against China’s yuan policy. “But…we all know the Chinese currency is deliberately undervalued

Or, as the new year dawns, ox in the China shop.

© 2010 Shopfloor | Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS)