A Bipartisan Call for Extending the Current Tax Rates

By September 17, 2010General, Taxation

Stephen Moore at The Wall Street Journal’s Political Diary takes note of the recent letter from 31 House Democrats urging the extension of the current tax rates for all income levels. By rejecting the “middle class tax cut” rhetoric, these House members are reflecting the views of their constituents, Moore reports in “Let Them Eat Tax Hikes.”

As a matter of political analysis, he concludes:

The best bet now is there will be no vote on the tax cut extensions in the House before the elections. Democrats will have to face voters in November essentially promising a tax hike on everyone in January. Now that’s tax fairness.

Rep. Harry Mitchell (D-AZ) posted the letter on his official website on Monday addresses to Speaker Pelosi and Majority Leader Hoyer:

We urge you to consider legislation to extend all of the income tax cuts contained in The Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 (P.L.#107-16).  In recent weeks, we have heard from a diverse spectrum of economists, small business owners, and families who have voiced concerns that raising any taxes right now could negatively impact economic growth.

Given the continued fragility of our economy and slow pace of recovery, we share their concerns.  We believe in times of economic recovery it makes good sense to maintain things as they are in the short term, to provide families and businesses the certainty required to plan and make sound budget decisions.  Providing this certainty will give small businesses, the backbone of our economic recovery, confidence and stability.

While those in the highest income brackets comprise only two to three percent of American taxpayers, economists estimate that they are responsible for 25 percent of national consumer spending.  As 70 percent of our economy is driven by consumer spending, this is not the time to jeopardize further growth.  It is also estimated that up to one-third of high-income taxpayers are small business owners, our nation’s job creators and the backbone of our economic recovery.

All tax cuts can be extended without violating statutory PAYGO.  Paying for a short-term extension of the high-income brackets is possible without accruing new debt by using existing surplus funds identified on the PAYGO scorecard, while the PAYGO law already allows for the middle class tax cuts to be extended.  This method protects all taxpayers by not adding further to our national debt.

This Congress has taken significant steps to create an environment for the private sector to create jobs.  GDP has moved from shrinking at a rate of more than six percent a year to four quarters of sustained growth.  After 18 months of private sector job losses, we have seen eight straight months of private sector job growth creating more than 760,000 jobs.  Consumer spending is also trending in a modest positive direction.  However, our economy is still recovering and decisive action needs to be taken to assist the recovery moving forward.

We urge quick passage of legislation to extend the tax cuts so that American families and businesses have the certainty required to plan and make informed decisions.  The sooner we act, the sooner our nation’s economy will benefit.

We look forward to working with you to extend all income tax rates.


Join the discussion One Comment

  • Red Arizonan says:

    Harry Mitchell is only calling for extending the tax cuts because he’s desperately trying to run to the right now that he’s facing a strong Republican challenger, David Schweikert, who is 12 points ahead of him in the polls, due to Miitchell’s voting record which has been
    lockstep with Pelosi and the Obama administration. He voted for Obamacare, some of the TARP bailouts, and cardcheck. He doesn’t support SB1070, which is even more popular in Arizona than it is in the rest of the country. He’s ignored the nonstop Tea Party protests outside his office, he doesn’t represent his Republican-leaning district. He is completely bought and paid for by the unions


    With early ballots going out in the mail in a couple of weeks, there is virtually no way Mitchell can catch up to Schweikert, there are too few undecided voters. The national Dems just announced they won’t be spending any money on his race, and the AFL-CIO and other labor
    unions have also decided not to spend any money on Arizona Congressional races. Whereas the NRCC is pouring money into the race to help Schweikert, along with the Club for Growth and independent expenditure committees like the 60 Plus Association. Thanks to 60+, Schweikert
    has more TV ads playing now than Mitchell. I predict Schweikert wins by close to double digits.

Leave a Reply