We were so busy getting under the limbo stick down in Orlando at the ISPA meeting last week that we missed this unbelievably excellent piece by the universally-respected Bob Samuelson on one of our favorite topics in the WaPo.
As noted climatologist Robert Redford gathers with a bunch of Mayors out in Sundance this week (Hey, what happened to Butch?), Samuelson’s article, entitled, “Greenhouse Guessing,” takes on the famed Stern manifesto and debunks at will. “The report,” he says in the very first paragraph, “is a masterpiece of misleading public relations.” Yeah, we knew that.
He then goes on to note that 34 of 41 developed countries monitored by the UN — virtually all Kyoto signatories — have failed to reduce greenhouse emissions from 2000 to 2004. No big shocker there as most EU countries will far exceed their allowable Kyoto limits. And Why? Opines Samuelson:
“First: With today’s technologies, we don’t know how to cut greenhouse gases in politically and economically acceptable ways…
Second: In rich democracies, policies that might curb greenhouse gases require politicians and the public to act in exceptionally “enlightened” (read: “unrealistic”) ways…
Third: Even if rich countries cut emissions, it won’t make much difference unless poor countries do likewise — and so far, they’ve refused because that might jeopardize their economic growth and poverty-reduction efforts.”
For good measure, Samuelson adds this:
“The other great distortion in Stern’s report involves global warming’s effects. No one knows what these might be, because we don’t know how much warming might occur, when, where or how easily people might adapt. Stern’s horrific specter distills many of the most terrifying guesses, including some imagined for the 22nd century, and implies that they’re imminent.”
Says Samuelson in conclusion simply, “We need more candor.” We couldn’t agree more, and would only add to candor, “Science.”
Click here to read the whole article.
Latest posts by NAM (see all)
- Manufacturers Win Several Website Design Awards - June 15, 2011
- China Makes Commitments on Trade, Intellectual Property - December 16, 2010
- ITC Details Widespread Theft of Intellectual Property in China - December 14, 2010